• This Month on WestView News
  • Featured
  • Monthly Columns
  • Editorials
  • Articles
  • Briefly Noted
  • WestViews
  • Photos
  • Front Page
  • About Us
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • EXTRA
WESTVIEW NEWS
Menu
  • This Month on WestView News
  • Featured
  • Monthly Columns
  • Editorials
  • Articles
  • Briefly Noted
  • WestViews
  • Photos
 › Articles › Editorials › Opinion › Politics › There is No Plan

There is No Plan

admin 07/03/2015     Articles, Editorials, Opinion, Politics

How Air Rights Could Radically Change the Waterfront (Part Two)

 

By Barry Benepe

 

Last month we emphasized the worst scenarios which could take place as the Hudson River Park starts to sell air rights.

 

Andrew Berman, Executive Director of the Greenwich Village Society for Historic Preservation, noted that the legislation—passed at the end of 2013 without any notification to the affected communities—allows the transfer of potentially millions of square feet of air rights from the Hudson River Park for additional development along four miles of shoreland one block inland.

 

This could take place in a thoughtful, intelligent way which will beautify and complement the edge of our waterfront park if the City Planning Commission plans appropriately and reaches out to get the community excited and involved.

 

Madelyn Wils, President and CEO of the Hudson River Park Trust, compares this district to the West Chelsea Special District—which preserves the High Line by allowing transfer of its air rights to properties in a carefully defined area surrounding it, including those along the Hudson River Park.

 

None of this can happen until, according to a spokesperson for the City Planning Department, “the development and adoption of a new zoning framework to allow transfers of unused development rights from the park to sites across route 9A [West Street].” Madelyn Wils has indicated that she would transfer such rights only from commercial piers, but that is speculation on her part since the local zoning law defining sending and receiving areas has not been drafted, much less passed.

 

At any rate, the existing piers with their enclosed sheds have virtually no rights to sell. The piers and platforms would have to be removed. Since they are a source of income for the Trust, that would be shooting itself in the foot. However, there are well over five hundred acres of “land under water” from the bulkhead line out eight hundred feet to the pier head line—provided there is a market for those “unused development rights.” A diagram in the Zoning Manual makes this concept clear.

 

The concept of salable “land under water” in NYC stems from the passing of the 1686 Donegan charter introduced by the second English governor, Thomas Donegan. It made underwater land into a form of property which could be bought and sold to provide docks and warehouses, and led to the creation of the M2-3 district to create piers where the park now sits. The Trust can thank Governor Donegan for its largess.

 

The four mile strip of inboard land to whose owners the Trust will turn to make deals already has millions of square feet of unused development rights permitting high rise buildings. At 59th Street, Douglas Durst is already building a 700 unit, one million square foot building designed by Bjarke Ingels Ground without purchasing development rights—it will rise like a shoe pointed toward the Hudson from a one story toe to a thirty-two story heel sloping around green gardens to the ground.

 

The City Planning Commission plays a crucial role in deciding how this four mile park boundary should develop—like Trump’s Riverside South or Richard Meier’s three buildings on Charles Lane? I believe the latter should be the model for Chelsea, the West Village, NOHO and SOHO, perhaps with occasional taller skinny accents at appropriate junctures.

 

It is time for City Planning to plan, to model their vision, locate sending and receiving sites and excite the community in the way the Friends of the High Line did at their beginning.

 

 

 Previous Post

Street Smarts

Next Post 

Science from Away: Kathleen Lonsdale—Against all odds.

Related Articles

Karen Rempel at UN Gala Honoring Joe Biden in 2017
Catch and Release
Hummel
Warhol and Wallowitch —a Gay Affair
Using Speech Recognition to Control Your Desktop and Programs
How Do I Love Thee? Let Me Count the Compliments
Our Way Out of This: I Think Not
From Ancient Sparta to Modern Denmark: The Rationalization of Eugenics
James E. Murphy, Consultant
It’s Just Politics
VID Endorses City Council Candidates
Being Black Isn’t a Crime
HOW SWEDE IT IS
Oxidative Phosphorylation: Life’s Energy Source
Participate as We Cover Local Elections
Polly Trottenberg – Good Riddance
Oxidative Phosphorylation: Life’s Energy Source
Palestinians Persecuted During the Pandemic
Book Review: Children’s Piano Primer 1 2 3 Do Re Mi 
Urban Native Artists Show at the Revelation Gallery
New York Time Capsule
I’m From Joe’s Hometown
Who’s the Dolly Parton Patron Saint of Curing AIDS?
Wenceslaus
Holly Claus Awakens Our Dreams
DAVID NORMAN DINKINS, 7/10/1927-11/23/2020
Who You Are in Times of Uncertainty
The Evolution of Winter Holidays: From Saturnalia to the Christmas Season
Could a Win at Beth Israel Be Near?
Goodbye Charlie
New York Apartment Prices Poised to Drop 20%
Vija Saved From the Government
Our Neighbors At NYCHA – New Crisis With Paint
Permanent Outdoor Dining? Government By Fiat—Without Caution
Joan’s Shanghai
SUPER HERO VIII: What the Cats Drag In
Reimagining Solutions
Mayor de Blasio: Billionaire’s Hand Puppet
Getting Specific About Your Anxiety

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

January 2020

Subscribe Now

January 2020

Donate Now

Read the Archives

Sign up for WestView News EXTRA

Copyright © WestView News