• This Month on WestView News
  • Featured
  • Monthly Columns
  • Editorials
  • Articles
  • Briefly Noted
  • WestViews
  • Photos
  • Front Page
  • About Us
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • EXTRA
WESTVIEW NEWS
Menu
  • This Month on WestView News
  • Featured
  • Monthly Columns
  • Editorials
  • Articles
  • Briefly Noted
  • WestViews
  • Photos
 › Articles › News › Consultants Kicked Off Gravy Train

Consultants Kicked Off Gravy Train

admin 07/03/2015     Articles, News

By Carol F. Yost

 

On May 5, the Daily News printed the dramatic story that, after years of outsourcing technical services to private vendors, New York City agencies are going to go in-house. Under the heading “City to In-Source Consultant Gigs, Save Millions,” they report that “city officials expect to save 3.6 million this year” and potentially “nearly $100 million over five years” by cutting off the “legions of $500,000-a-year consultants camped at scores of city agencies for years.”

 

The practice of outsourcing had been in place for more than twenty years, the article said, and it cited the colossal and very expensive failure of Northrup-Grumman in its attempt to fix the 911 system as an example of why privatization of needed services was a bad idea. The project was turned over to City workers.

 

For too long, the attitude has been that for-profit consultants or companies, with their money-making incentive and drive, could do a job more efficiently and better than City drudges. That’s changing. The privatization cost the City more, often did not yield better results, and was unfair to City workers—union members—who had toiled in the system, rising through the ranks after taking tough civil service exams; it made for fewer jobs being available to them, and insultingly implied that they just couldn’t be as good as outside consultants who often were paid much more. Now, job titles that are normally outsourced are being changed to regular city-agency positions.

 

A central pool of IT technicians is also planned, based at the Department of Information Technology and Telecommunications; they will be able to go from agency to agency to handle different projects as needed.

 

I recall one instance of a private consultant at HPD, where I was working at the time, a dozen years ago. Rafael Naveh seemed a quiet, unassuming man who for at least ten years was in charge of overseeing our entire computer system, which agency heads hoped to maintain as state-of-the-art.

 

Meanwhile, I knew a number of top-flight City workers who could surely have done an excellent job in the same position; they had style, too, and “the chops,” as they say. No drudges, these. But Raffi, originally from Israel, was nice, and he padded around in a gray flannel pajama-like outfit all day long, not bothering with the stylish duds some of the City techs wore.

 

Then on January 27, 2003, an article appeared in the New York Post, embarrassing the agency considerably and shocking many of its own employees. A photo of a McMansion in a leafy suburb accompanied the article. It was Raffi’s Paramus, NJ, home. He was bringing in $437,272 a year—much more than any City worker ever could, and in fact it was more than our Governor, our Mayor (if Bloomberg had accepted a salary), and even our President was being paid.

 

HPD management, interviewed for the article, had quickly responded that to get the best, you had to pay for it; after all, you were competing with private firms for the greatest talent. But with the appearance of the article the damage was done. This was a time when the City was facing a multibillion-dollar debt, and the Mayor (though not a friend of unions or City workers in general) had ordered agencies to cut costs. Shortly, after stroking its agency chin and reflecting upon the matter, HPD quietly terminated Raffi’s contract and turned to its well-dressed but lower-paid in-house staff.

 

 

 Previous Post

No Safe Walkway

Next Post 

A Fond Farewell

Related Articles

Karen Rempel at UN Gala Honoring Joe Biden in 2017
Catch and Release
Hummel
Warhol and Wallowitch —a Gay Affair
Using Speech Recognition to Control Your Desktop and Programs
How Do I Love Thee? Let Me Count the Compliments
Our Way Out of This: I Think Not
From Ancient Sparta to Modern Denmark: The Rationalization of Eugenics
James E. Murphy, Consultant
It’s Just Politics
VID Endorses City Council Candidates
Being Black Isn’t a Crime
HOW SWEDE IT IS
Oxidative Phosphorylation: Life’s Energy Source
Participate as We Cover Local Elections
Polly Trottenberg – Good Riddance
Oxidative Phosphorylation: Life’s Energy Source
Palestinians Persecuted During the Pandemic
Book Review: Children’s Piano Primer 1 2 3 Do Re Mi 
Urban Native Artists Show at the Revelation Gallery
New York Time Capsule
I’m From Joe’s Hometown
Who’s the Dolly Parton Patron Saint of Curing AIDS?
Wenceslaus
Holly Claus Awakens Our Dreams
DAVID NORMAN DINKINS, 7/10/1927-11/23/2020
Who You Are in Times of Uncertainty
The Evolution of Winter Holidays: From Saturnalia to the Christmas Season
Could a Win at Beth Israel Be Near?
Goodbye Charlie
New York Apartment Prices Poised to Drop 20%
Vija Saved From the Government
Our Neighbors At NYCHA – New Crisis With Paint
Permanent Outdoor Dining? Government By Fiat—Without Caution
Joan’s Shanghai
SUPER HERO VIII: What the Cats Drag In
Reimagining Solutions
Mayor de Blasio: Billionaire’s Hand Puppet
Getting Specific About Your Anxiety

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

January 2020

Subscribe Now

January 2020

Donate Now

Read the Archives

Sign up for WestView News EXTRA

Copyright © WestView News